BAJAJ ASSET MANAGEMENT LIMITED.

Gold ETF vs Silver ETF: Differences, Returns and Which to Choose

Gold and silver exchange-traded funds (ETFs) aim to track domestic prices of their respective metals. Gold generally experiences smaller price swings than silver. Silver prices also respond strongly to industrial demand, including electronics, solar technology and manufacturing.

Both provide metal exposure without requiring you to store physical bullion. The gold ETF vs silver ETF decision comes down to the exposure you want, the price fluctuations you can accept and the costs of the specific scheme. Neither offers fixed returns or protection from losses.

What is a gold ETF?

A gold ETF is a mutual fund scheme that invests in gold and permitted gold-related instruments to track domestic gold prices.

You buy units on a stock exchange and hold them in a demat account, which stores securities electronically. You own units of the scheme rather than a particular gold bar.

Gold prices respond to investment demand, jewellery purchases, central-bank activity, interest rates and currency movements. These factors can cause a gold ETF’s value to rise or fall.

Key Takeaways

  • Gold ETFs track gold prices, while silver ETFs track silver prices, subject to expenses and tracking differences.
  • Silver generally experiences sharper price movements because it responds to both investment and industrial demand.
  • Both remove the need to store bullion yourself, but retain the risk of falling metal prices.
  • Compare each ETF’s expenses, tracking, trading liquidity and market price before investing.
  • Under current rules, listed gold and silver ETF gains generally qualify for long-term taxation after a holding period exceeding 12 months.

What is a silver ETF?

A silver ETF is a mutual fund scheme that invests in silver and permitted silver-related instruments to track domestic silver prices. Its units also trade on stock exchanges and are held in a demat account.

Silver has both investment and industrial uses. Strong manufacturing demand can support prices, while weaker industrial activity can weigh on them. Investor buying, interest rates and currency movements also influence silver.

Industrial growth does not guarantee rising silver ETF returns. Supply changes, substitution and the price already paid by investors matter too.

How do gold and silver ETFs work?

The fund holds investments according to its mandate, while investors buy and sell its units through an exchange. Two values matter:

  • Net Asset Value (NAV): The scheme’s assets minus its liabilities, divided by the number of outstanding units.
  • Exchange price: The price at which buyers and sellers transact during market hours.

The exchange price can be above or below NAV. Compare the quote with the latest indicative NAV, an estimate of the portfolio’s per-unit value during trading hours. Check its timestamp because the underlying data may not update continuously.

From 1 April 2026, the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) requires mutual funds to value physical gold and silver using specified polled spot prices published by recognised stock exchanges. These prices are collected from market participants under the prescribed framework.

This valuation method does not mean you will always buy or sell ETF units at NAV.

Source: SEBI, circular dated 26 February 2026 on valuation of physical gold and silver held by mutual fund schemes.

What are the differences between gold ETFs and silver ETFs?

The underlying metal is the main difference, but entry costs and trading conditions also deserve attention:

ConsiderationGold ETFsSilver ETFs
Investment exposureGold and permitted gold-related instrumentsSilver and permitted silver-related instruments
Main demand driversInvestment, jewellery and central-bank demandIndustrial use, investment, jewellery and silverware
Price fluctuationsGenerally less volatile than silver, although substantial declines remain possibleGenerally experiences sharper price movements
Physical metal purityGold bullion is generally 99.5% purity or higherPhysical silver follows the prescribed 99.9% purity standard
Industrial sensitivityIndustrial demand plays a smaller roleManufacturing, electronics and solar demand have greater influence
Minimum exchange investmentGenerally one unit at its traded price, plus applicable chargesGenerally one unit at its traded price, plus applicable charges
LiquidityDepends on the specific ETF’s available orders, spreads and market-making arrangementsDepends on the same factors
CostsScheme expenses and applicable trading and account chargesThe same cost categories, with amounts varying by scheme and broker
Capital-gains treatmentGenerally long-term after more than 12 months for listed unitsGenerally the same treatment

A silver ETF is not automatically cheaper to enter because silver costs less per gram. ETF unit sizes differ, so compare the actual unit price and trading lot.

Sources: SEBI, mutual fund framework and gold and silver ETF operating norms.

How should you compare gold ETF vs silver ETF returns?

Neither category consistently delivers higher returns. The result depends on the period selected, domestic metal-price movements and the scheme’s expenses and tracking.

For a single purchase and sale, with no interim distributions:

Return (%) = [(Selling price − Purchase price) ÷ Purchase price] × 100

For example, an ETF unit bought at ₹100 and sold at ₹110 earns 10% before transaction costs and taxes. A unit bought at ₹20 and sold at ₹22 also earns 10%. The lower unit price does not produce a better percentage return.

For a useful gold ETF vs silver ETF returns comparison:

  • Use identical dates: Compare both investments over the same period.
  • Use the same measure: Do not compare a total three-year gain with an annualised three-year return.
  • Compare ETF returns: A metal’s price change is not the same as an investor’s ETF return.
  • Review declines: Look at losses during difficult periods alongside gains.
  • Account for your trading prices: Buying above NAV or selling below it can affect your outcome.

Published NAV returns already reflect scheme expenses. Do not subtract the expense ratio again. Your brokerage, other transaction costs and personal taxes still affect what you keep.

The figures shown are for illustrative purpose only

What are the benefits and risks of gold and silver ETFs?

Both routes remove some practical difficulties of owning bullion while retaining exposure to metal-price movements.

What benefits do they share?

  • No personal bullion storage: The scheme arranges custody of its physical holdings.
  • No jewellery-making charges: Your investment does not involve paying for jewellery design or craftsmanship.
  • Exchange access: You can place buy and sell orders during trading hours.
  • Published information: Portfolio, NAV, expense and tracking disclosures help you evaluate the scheme.
  • Diversification: Precious metals can behave differently from shares and bonds, although that relationship changes.

What risks should you understand?

  • Price risk: Both metals can decline, including over extended periods.
  • Sharper silver fluctuations: Changes in industrial demand can add to silver’s price swings.
  • Liquidity risk: Available orders may be insufficient for the quantity you want to trade.
  • Premium or discount risk: Your trading price can differ from the portfolio’s per-unit value.
  • Concentration risk: Holding both metals still leaves that allocation dependent on precious metals.

Gold and silver do not themselves pay interest. Neither ETF should be treated as a source of assured regular income or guaranteed inflation protection.

What should you check before choosing an ETF?

After deciding which metal fits your needs, compare individual schemes using these checks.

What are the total costs?

The Total Expense Ratio (TER) covers annual scheme expenses charged to its assets and reflected in NAV. Also check brokerage, transaction charges and applicable demat-account fees. The bid–ask spread, the gap between available buying and selling prices, adds another trading cost.

A low expense ratio does not necessarily mean the lowest total cost if the ETF is expensive to buy or sell.

How closely does it track its benchmark?

Compare tracking errors and tracking differences. Tracking difference is the return gap between the fund and its benchmark. Tracking error measures how much the daily return gap varies. These are performance measures, not separate fees. Review them over comparable periods rather than choosing on expense ratio alone.

Can you trade the amount you need?

Check available buying and selling quantities, the spread and recent trading activity. A large fund size alone does not guarantee enough exchange orders at your preferred price.

Compare the quote with indicative NAV. Paying substantially above the portfolio’s indicative value can hurt your return if that premium later disappears.

Does the scheme’s risk level suit you?

Read the investment objective, portfolio and Riskometer, which indicates the scheme’s risk level. Neither the gold nor silver label replaces a review of the specific product.

Sources: NSE, ETF investor guidance; SEBI, tracking and risk-disclosure framework.

How are gold and silver ETFs taxed in India?

For resident individuals holding listed gold and silver ETF units as investments, the general treatment under current rules is:

Holding periodGeneral tax treatment
12 months or lessShort-Term Capital Gains (STCG), added to taxable income and taxed at applicable slab rates
More than 12 monthsLong-Term Capital Gains (LTCG), generally taxed at 12.5% without indexation, meaning no inflation adjustment to the purchase cost

Health and Education Cess of 4% applies to the tax, with surcharge where applicable. The ₹1.25 lakh annual threshold for qualifying equity LTCG does not apply to these ETF gains.

Tax applies to the gain, not the entire sale proceeds. Earlier transactions may fall under different rules, so use the provisions applicable to the year of sale.

An unlisted gold or silver fund of funds is a different product and generally requires a holding period exceeding 24 months for long-term treatment.

The tax information in this article is based on prevailing laws at the time of publishing the article and is subject to change. Please consult a tax professional or refer to the latest regulations for up-to-date information.

Sources: Income Tax Department, capital-gains guidance; AMFI, mutual fund tax guidance.

Gold ETF, silver ETF or both: which should you choose?

Start with the role you want precious metals to play in your portfolio.

When might you consider a gold ETF?

A gold ETF may fit if you:

  • Want gold exposure without storing physical bullion.
  • Prefer a metal that generally fluctuates less than silver.
  • Can accept periods of falling prices and returns that may not keep pace with inflation.

When might you consider a silver ETF?

A silver ETF may fit if you:

  • Want exposure to silver’s investment and industrial demand.
  • Can accept sharper price movements.
  • Can remain invested without depending on a quick sale for essential expenses.

Higher volatility does not guarantee higher returns. A lower unit price or strong recent performance is not enough reason to choose silver.

When might holding both make sense?

A well-diversified portfolio may include both gold and silver ETFs if their combined allocation fits your goals and ability to handle losses.

Set the total precious-metal allocation first, then decide how to divide it. Include existing jewellery, coins and other metal investments in that review. Holding both metals does not replace diversification across other assets. You do not need either ETF if precious-metal exposure does not fit your financial goals.

How can you invest in gold and silver ETFs?

Buying either ETF through an exchange generally involves these steps:

  1. Complete Know Your Customer (KYC) requirements and open trading and demat accounts with a SEBI-registered broker.
  2. Compare schemes using their objectives, Riskometer, expenses, tracking and trading conditions.
  3. Check the correct exchange symbol and review available prices and quantities.
  4. Compare the quote with indicative NAV, noting its update time.
  5. Place your order. A limit order sets the maximum buying price you will accept but does not guarantee execution.
  6. Confirm the trade and check the units in your demat account after settlement.

Keep money needed for immediate expenses separately. Exchange access does not guarantee that you can sell the required quantity at your preferred price.

FAQs

Which ETF is better, silver or gold?

Neither is automatically better. Gold generally experiences smaller price swings, while silver has greater industrial sensitivity. Compare their role in your portfolio, the losses you can afford and the costs and trading conditions of the specific schemes.

What does “silver gold ETF” mean?

The phrase does not identify a precise investment structure. Separate gold and silver ETFs track their respective metals. A fund offering combined exposure may invest through underlying ETFs, so read its objective and allocation before assuming what it holds.

Are gold and silver ETFs safer than physical metals?

They remove the need to store bullion yourself and arrange purity checks. They still carry market, trading and operational risks. A regulated fund structure does not guarantee returns or prevent losses.

Can gold and silver ETFs be held in the same demat account?

Yes. You can generally hold both in the same demat account used for other eligible securities. Separate accounts are not required for each metal.

Can I invest regularly through an SIP?

Some brokers offer scheduled ETF purchases resembling a Systematic Investment Plan (SIP), subject to execution and unit availability. Alternatively, eligible gold or silver funds of funds offer mutual fund SIPs, with different expenses and tax holding periods.

Can I invest without a demat account?

Direct exchange purchases generally require demat and trading accounts. A gold or silver fund of funds can provide exposure through underlying ETFs without a demat account, subject to the scheme’s terms.

Can I hold a gold ETF for the long term?

Yes. However, a long holding period does not guarantee a profit. Review whether the allocation remains appropriate as your goals, portfolio and spending deadlines change.

Will I receive physical gold or silver when I sell ETF units?

An ordinary exchange sale gives you cash proceeds, not bullion. Direct physical redemption, where available, follows scheme-specific eligibility and large-unit requirements. It should not be assumed to be available for a small retail holding.

Related Searches

BSE MidcapNifty Microcap 250Nifty Midcap 150 Index
Nifty Next 50Gift NiftySemiconductor ETF
NSE HolidaysTax on Intraday TradingMicro Cap Mutual Funds

Start an SIP

Every long-term goal begins with a simple step. Explore mutual funds from Bajaj AMC and choose between equity, debt, hybrid and passive funds. Start an SIP to invest regularly, build consistency, and potentially achieve your financial goals.

Get A Call Back

Want help planning your investments?

Share your details and our experts will guide you.

By submitting my details, I agree to receive a call from
Bajaj AMC for assistance.

Grow wealth with mutual funds

Must Read

GIFT Nifty
What is GIFT Nifty? Meaning of GIFT Nifty explained

GIFT Nifty refers to US dollar-denominated Nifty derivatives traded on

Different Types of STP in Mutual Funds
What is STP in Mutual Funds: Meaning, Types, Full Form & Benefits

An investment instrument that has gained popularity among investors is

Nifty 50 Index Live Today

If you follow the Indian stock market, you have probably

Calculators

FAQs

Fund Collections

Disclaimer

Mutual Fund investments are subject to market risks, read all scheme related documents carefully.
This document should not be treated as endorsement of the views/opinions or as investment advice. This document should not be construed as a research report or a recommendation to buy or sell any security. This document is for information purpose only and should not be construed as a promise on minimum returns or safeguard of capital. This document alone is not sufficient and should not be used for the development or implementation of an investment strategy. The recipient should note and understand that the information provided above may not contain all the material aspects relevant for making an investment decision. Investors are advised to consult their own investment advisor before making any investment decision in light of their risk appetite, investment goals and horizon. This information is subject to change without any prior notice.
The content herein has been prepared on the basis of publicly available information believed to be reliable. However, Bajaj Asset Management Limited (formerly known as Bajaj Finserv Asset Management Limited) does not guarantee the accuracy of such information, assure its completeness or warrant such information will not be changed. The tax information (if any) in this article is based on prevailing laws at the time of publishing the article and is subject to change. Please consult a tax professional or refer to the latest regulations for up-to-date information.

Login/Signup