Multi asset allocation fund vs. Dynamic asset funds: Key differences

Posted On: 05 June 2024

Investing in a multi-asset allocation fund or a dynamic asset allocation fund can be a great way to grow your money. Both types of funds offer ways to invest in different types of assets, such as stocks, bonds, and gold. However, they work in different ways and can suit different types of investors.

Let’s take a closer look at what multi-asset allocation funds and dynamic asset allocation funds are and how they work. By understanding the difference between multi-asset allocation funds and dynamic asset funds, investors can choose the one that aligns with their financial goals and requirements.

Table of contents

What is Multi asset allocation funds (MAA Funds)
Advantages of Multi Asset Allocation Funds
What are dynamic asset allocation funds (DAA Funds)
Advantages of Dynamic Asset Allocation Funds
Multi-asset allocation vs. dynamic asset allocation funds
Multi-asset allocation vs. dynamic asset allocation funds: key differences
Multi-asset allocation vs. dynamic asset allocation funds: choosing a suitable fund

What is Multi asset allocation funds (MAA Funds)

A multi-asset allocation fund invests in various types of assets like stocks, bonds, and gold. This type of fund aims to spread risk across different asset classes. By investing in a mix of assets, a multi asset allocation fund can provide relatively stable returns compared to investing in just one type of asset. The fund manager decides how much money to put into each type of asset, based on the fund's goals and market conditions. These funds are generally less risky than pure equity funds because they spread investments across different asset types.

Advantages of multi asset allocation funds

Multi-asset allocation funds offer several advantages, especially for investors looking for a balanced approach. Here are a few key benefits:

Easy diversification: Multi-asset allocation funds provide a one-stop solution for diversification, eliminating the need for investors to research and invest in multiple individual funds or assets.
Risk management: By investing across various asset classes (such as equities, bonds, and sometimes commodities), these funds can reduce the overall risk compared to investing in a single asset class.
Professional management: These funds are typically managed by experienced professionals who monitor and adjust the allocation based on market conditions, aiming for optimal returns while managing risk.
Dynamic management: Fund managers can freely adjust the asset mix in response to changing economic conditions or market opportunities. This flexibility allows managers to increase exposure to assets with stronger growth potential or reduce exposure to more volatile sectors, potentially enhancing returns and reducing risk.

What are dynamic asset allocation funds (DAA Funds)

Dynamic asset allocation funds also invest in different types of assets. However, the key difference between a multi-asset allocation fund and a dynamic asset fund is that, in the latter, the allocation to each asset class changes frequently based on market conditions. The fund manager actively adjusts the investment mix to take advantage of market trends and reduce risk. For example, if the stock market is expected to perform well, the fund might increase its investment in stocks. On the other hand, if the market is expected to decline, the fund might reduce its stock holdings and increase investments in bonds or other stable assets.

Advantages of dynamic asset allocation funds

Dynamic asset allocation funds are designed to actively adjust their asset mix in response to market conditions. Here are several key advantages of these funds:

Flexibility in market response: Dynamic asset allocation funds have the flexibility to shift between asset classes (such as stocks, bonds, and cash) based on market movements and economic signals, potentially capitalising on opportunities as they arise.
Risk management: By adjusting asset allocation in response to market conditions, these funds can reduce exposure to risky assets during market downturns.
Return potential: Dynamic adjustments allow fund managers to take advantage of favourable market conditions for certain asset classes, leading to a more optimal risk-return balance compared to static allocation strategies. If you wish to start an SIP in these funds, you can make use of an SIP return calculator to estimate the growth of your investments over time.
Hands-off approach: Dynamic allocation takes the burden off investors to monitor and rebalance portfolios themselves, as professional managers handle adjustments, which can save time and effort for investors.

Multi-asset allocation vs. dynamic asset allocation funds

Choosing between a multi-asset allocation fund and a dynamic asset fund depends on your investment goals and risk tolerance. If you prefer a relatively stable investment with moderate risk, a multi-asset allocation fund might be a suitable choice. These funds offer diversification and are less likely to experience large swings in value. They invest in a fixed proportion of different assets, providing a balanced approach that can cushion against market volatility. Multi-asset allocation funds are ideal for investors who desire steady growth and want to minimise the impact of market fluctuations on their portfolios.

On the other hand, if you are comfortable with a relatively higher level of risk and are looking for potentially higher returns, a dynamic asset fund might suit you. These funds actively change their investment mix to try to optimize returns and manage risk according to market conditions. Dynamic asset funds are more flexible and can quickly adapt to changing market situations. This active management can potentially yield higher returns during favourable market conditions. However, it also means that these funds can be more volatile and may experience greater fluctuations in value.

When deciding between the two, consider your investment horizon and financial goals. If you have a long-term perspective and prefer a hands-off approach, a multi-asset allocation fund may provide the stability and consistent growth you need.

Multi-asset allocation vs. dynamic asset allocation funds: key differences

Both multi asset allocation funds and dynamic asset allocation funds aim to provide diversification and manage risk, but they differ in their strategies.

Multi asset allocation funds maintain a stable mix of asset classes, such as equity, debt, and gold, based on long-term considerations. The allocation is adjusted infrequently, focusing on returns and risk mitigation through diversification.

Dynamic asset allocation funds, however, adjust their asset allocation actively based on market conditions. This approach allows fund managers to potentially capitalize on market trends and reduce exposure during volatile periods by altering asset class allocations based on market assessments.

Investment approach:

Multi asset allocation funds follow a relatively stable allocation strategy, while dynamic asset allocation funds adjust allocations actively based on market conditions.

Multi asset allocation funds aim for relatively steady returns, while dynamic asset allocation funds focus on potentially higher returns through active management.

Risk management:

Multi-asset allocation funds manage risk mainly through diversification, while dynamic asset allocation funds may also use tactical strategies to address risk.

Dynamic asset allocation funds may be more suitable for investors with a higher risk tolerance due to their increased return volatility.

Suitability for investors:

Multi-asset allocation funds may be suitable for investors seeking a more stable investment experience.

Dynamic asset allocation funds may be suitable for investors comfortable with higher volatility and seeking potentially greater returns.

Multi-asset allocation vs. dynamic asset allocation funds: choosing a suitable fund

The choice between multi-asset allocation and dynamic asset allocation funds depends on your personal investment goals, risk tolerance, and time horizon.

Multi-asset allocation funds may be suitable for you if:

- You seek a relatively stable and predictable investment experience.

- You have a moderate risk tolerance and prefer to avoid significant fluctuations in your portfolio.

- You have a long-term investment horizon and can handle short-term market volatility.

Dynamic asset allocation funds may be suitable for you if:

- You are comfortable with higher levels of risk and volatility.

- You are looking for the potential for higher returns than what a multi-asset allocation fund may offer.

- You have a shorter investment horizon and can accept potential short-term losses in exchange for the chance of higher returns.

Conclusion

Both multi-asset allocation funds and dynamic asset allocation funds offer distinct approaches to investing. Multi-asset allocation funds provide a diversified portfolio with a relatively stable asset mix. They are well-suited for investors seeking a balanced approach with a focus on long-term growth and risk mitigation.

Dynamic asset allocation funds, on the other hand, actively adjust their portfolio based on market conditions. This flexibility can potentially lead to reasonable returns but may also increase volatility. These funds are more suitable for investors with a higher risk tolerance who are willing to accept greater fluctuations in their portfolio value.

The choice between a multi-asset allocation fund and a dynamic asset allocation fund depends on your individual investment objectives, risk tolerance, time horizon, and financial situation.

FAQs

What is the difference between dynamic asset allocation fund and multi asset fund?

The key difference lies in the level of active management. Multi-asset funds focus on diversification with a relatively stable asset allocation, offering lesser volatility. Dynamic asset allocation funds, on the other hand, actively adjust their allocation based on market conditions, leading to higher volatility but potentially higher returns.

What type of investor should consider multi-asset allocation funds?

Multi-asset funds suit investors with long-term horizons, and those seeking diversification. They are ideal for busy individuals who prefer professional management and a balanced risk-return approach. These funds help investors seeking long-term growth while effectively managing risk across various asset classes.

Are dynamic asset allocation funds suitable for conservative investors?

Dynamic asset allocation funds may not suit highly conservative investors due to their higher volatility and potential for significant drawdowns. These funds focus on growth, which might not align with conservative investors' priority of capital preservation. Alternatives like debt, liquid, and money market funds offer more stability.

How does the tax treatment differ between these two fund types?

Dynamic asset allocation funds are often taxed as equity funds due to their higher equity exposure. For multi-asset funds the tax treatment varies depending on the fund's equity exposure.

What factors should I consider before choosing between multi-asset and dynamic allocation funds?

When choosing between multi-asset and dynamic asset allocation funds, consider risk tolerance, investment horizon, and goals. Multi-asset funds suit moderate risk with stable returns, while dynamic funds target higher returns but with increased volatility. Dynamic funds depend on fund manager expertise, making them suitable for higher risk tolerance.

Mutual Fund investments are subject to market risks, read all scheme related documents carefully.
This document should not be treated as endorsement of the views/opinions or as investment advice. This document should not be construed as a research report or a recommendation to buy or sell any security. This document is for information purpose only and should not be construed as a promise on minimum returns or safeguard of capital. This document alone is not sufficient and should not be used for the development or implementation of an investment strategy. The recipient should note and understand that the information provided above may not contain all the material aspects relevant for making an investment decision. Investors are advised to consult their own investment advisor before making any investment decision in light of their risk appetite, investment goals and horizon. This information is subject to change without any prior notice.