Narrative Investing: Why A Good Story May Beat Good Numbers

Consider this scenario: in a magazine, you read about two different start-ups. One is talking about statistics and the projections they expect to see in the coming years while another is promising to reinvent the future with self-driving cars powered by artificial intelligence. Which grabs more attention? For many investors, it’s the second one, even if the numbers may not add up. That instinct is the essence of narrative investing: the pull of a story may feel more persuasive than traditional analysis and statistics.

Table of contents

• What do we mean by narrative investing?
• Real world stories that moved markets
• Why stories may carry hidden risks
• Finding balance between story and substance
• The mindset of a thoughtful investor

What do we mean by narrative investing?

Narrative investing is essentially investing in an idea rather than a spreadsheet. In behavioural finance, researchers explain that human beings are storytelling creatures. Data feels abstract, but a strong narrative is easy to understand, remember, and share. When someone talks about ‘the next big thing in energy’ or ‘AI transforming jobs’, it may spark curiosity and imagination.

Storytelling in stocks can simplify complexity and form a connection, making people feel like they are part of a movement. That emotional connection may drive valuations far higher than what cash flows or profits alone would justify.

Also Read: How Money Narratives Shape Financial Decisions

Real world stories that moved markets

The world has seen plenty of stories that took hold of investors. Electric vehicles (EVs) carry the potential of greener transport, artificial intelligence paints a picture of limitless productivity, and cryptocurrencies offer the vision of money free from central control. Each of these themes had pulled in massive capital long before clear earnings were visible.

This pattern isn’t new. The late 1990s dot-com bubble was built almost entirely on narrative.

India has had its own stories. The rapid rise of digital payments, especially after UPI’s launch, created excitement that drew both retail investors and global funds into fintech. Renewable energy has become another buzzword, with solar and wind companies starting to attract attention as the country aims for ambitious climate targets.

Why stories may carry hidden risks

Stories can be inspiring, but they may come with pitfalls. The most common is overvaluation: prices running ahead of earnings because everyone might buy into the theme. Herd behaviour reinforces this: investors may see others rushing in, assume the story must be true, and join without much questioning.

When narratives break, corrections may be brutal. Behavioural finance explains why: confirmation bias may make us ignore warnings that don’t fit the story, while availability bias may make us focus on dramatic success stories rather than quieter failures. For instance, people may often recall the meteoric rise of a few EV stocks but tend to forget the dozens of companies in the sector that lost value.

Finding balance between story and substance

Does this imply that investors should steer clear of stories entirely? Not necessarily. Stories may identify opportunities ahead of hard facts. The trick may be to balance enthusiasm with restraint. Here are some practical strategies that may help:

• Verify the fundamentals: Even if earnings are early-stage, is there a well-defined business model and expanding market?
• Compare valuations: Evaluate ratios such as price-to-earnings or price-to-sales against industry standards.
• Use a checklist: Jot down your own absolute requirements, including management quality, balance-sheet integrity, or market share. Referencing this list may help keep feelings in check.
• Diversify risk: It’s advised to not put all your eggs in one basket. Rather, you may divide investments among several stories and old-school industries. Then, a troubled narrative is unlikely to potentially sink your portfolio.
• Monitor sentiment: Too much hype from media or unexpected surges in volumes may be warning signs that the narrative is getting ahead of itself.

The mindset of a thoughtful investor

In the end, narrative investing can teach us something humbling: markets may be guided by people as well as by numbers. Forgetting stories altogether may mean to miss out on promising themes; but listening too hard to them may risk potential losses. A balanced investor may embrace both possibilities. Stories are meant to be heard, but they might also have to be tested against fundamentals.

Understanding our own behavioural biases, whether it's blind optimism or fear of missing out, may prevent us from making potentially expensive errors.

Also Read: What is Investment: Meaning, Types and How to Start

Conclusion

Stories can have a bigger impact, even when it comes to the world of investing. Recognising the role of narrative investing may help us understand why compelling stories sometimes seem more attractive than compelling numbers. By balancing the inspiration of a good story with the discipline of fundamentals, investors may make more informed decisions.

At Bajaj Finserv AMC, we recognise that emotions are the cornerstone of investor behaviour – not just for investors but for investment professionals too. That’s why, behavioural finance is at the heart of our investment philosophy, InQuBe, which combines the Information Edge, Quantitative Edge and Behavioural Edge. By understanding, tracking and monitoring market sentiments and our own investment biases, we seek to make mindful and strategic investment decisions. Get the Behavioural edge by investing with Bajaj Finserv AMC. Read more about InQuBehere.

Mutual Fund investments are subject to market risks, read all scheme related documents carefully.

This document should not be treated as endorsement of the views/opinions or as investment advice. This document should not be construed as a research report or a recommendation to buy or sell any security. This document is for information purpose only and should not be construed as a promise on minimum returns or safeguard of capital. This document alone is not sufficient and should not be used for the development or implementation of an investment strategy. The recipient should note and understand that the information provided above may not contain all the material aspects relevant for making an investment decision. Investors are advised to consult their own investment advisor before making any investment decision in light of their risk appetite, investment goals and horizon. This information is subject to change without any prior notice.

The content herein has been prepared on the basis of publicly available information believed to be reliable. However, Bajaj Finserv Asset Management Ltd. does not guarantee the accuracy of such information, assure its completeness or warrant such information will not be changed.The tax information (if any) in this article is based on current laws and is subject to change. Please consult a tax professional or refer to the latest regulations for up-to-date information.